Musings, Nits, and Praises: Bienvenidos a los estados unidos?

Musings, Nits, and Praises

A farrago of all things deemed blog-worthy by a music-loving, poetry-writing, humor-seeking English teacher


Bienvenidos a los estados unidos?

With this week's "Day Without [Illegal] Immigrants"* being the latest log tossed onto the debate concerning what to do about illegal immigration, I couldn't help but think of Genesis' 1983 goofy tune "Illegal Alien" and the line "Consideration for your fellow man/ would not hurt anybody/it sure fits in with my plan." At first the thought of the song gave me a chuckle, but then I began giving some more serious consideration as to what a Christian stance on illegal immigration would be. On one hand, we're called to serve "the least of these" and to live out the Golden Rule. However, we are also commanded to follow the laws of the land unless they conflict with God's will.

*I read several articles on major news networks' websites concerning Monday's rallies, and the word "illegal" didn't appear until about 3/4 of the way through the articles. Politcal correctness is truly nauseating.

So is cracking down on illegal immigration--jailing illegal immigrants or at least sending them back to their native country--contradictory to God's command to love one another? Perhaps I'm a bit too calloused concerning the matter. Certainly I feel sympathy for people who receive little if any governmental care and desire a better life, but I don't think it's justifiable to do so illegally. It's incredibly unjust for people who have immigrated to our country legally--it reminds me a bit of people who cut in line, only a lot worse.

As for Monday's rallies, the gist of the rallies was "we deserve rights because we help the economy." Although illegal immigrants do, in fact, provide cheap labor and help perpetuate some portion of the economy, they also burden health care and education systems (and both systems have ample problems without illegal immigrants) and don't pay taxes. Furthermore, how can you demand the rights of a citizen if you aren't a legal citizen? (I suppose you can when you drive the issue on emotion and sweep logic and legality out of the way.) I also have a hard time mustering a pro-amnesty attitude when the rallies were rife with foreign flags, skewing the proverbial "melting pot" notion.


Of course, rather than a lot of congressional headbutting over border control, guest worker programs, etc., the easiest solution would be to make Mexico our 51st state or just storm down there with a good old -fashioned invasion.


Yes, I'm kidding.


4 Responses to “Bienvenidos a los estados unidos?”

  1. # Blogger Chad Gardner

    Why are they so concerened about being felons if caught? They're already committing a crime. Why not go for the gold and make it a felony!  

  2. # Blogger Jason

    I suspect the government will deliberate on the matter for another few years, all the while allowing more people to enter the country illegally.  

  3. # Anonymous Anonymous

    now I know it..  

  4. # Anonymous Anonymous

    я так считаю: восхитительно!! а82ч  

Post a Comment

Links to this post

Create a Link



© 2006 Musings, Nits, and Praises | No part of the content or the blog may be reproduced without prior written permission.
Learn how to